Teletraan I: The Transformers Wiki

Welcome to Teletraan I: The Transformers Wiki. You may wish to create or login to an account in order to have full editing access to this wiki.

READ MORE

Teletraan I: The Transformers Wiki
No edit summary
No edit summary
(24 intermediate revisions by 19 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
'''Pokeformers''' is a derogatory term often used to refer to<!--mostly--> the [[Armada (franchise)|''Armada'' franchise]] by members of the Transformers fandom who weren't particularly fond of the series. The term is a [[wikipedia:portmanteau|portmanteau]] of the words "[[Wikipedia:Pokémon(anime)|Pokémon]]" and "Transformers".
[[Image:Anothercon pikachu.jpg|250px|right]]
 
   
 
Some fans began referring to ''Armada'' as "Pokeformers" because of superficial similarities between the two franchise's premises: each featured a collection of small, cute characters with amazing powers and [[Targetmaster#Japanese Targetmasters|limited vocal skills]] which buyers were urged to collect as many of as they could, as well as having similar-sounding names. The ''Armada'' animated series did little to help refute this comparison, with the first half of the show featuring virtually nothing ''but'' the Transformers searching for new [[Mini-Cons]] in an attempt to "collect them all" - ironically taking the theme to an even greater extent than the Pokémon cartoon itself, which only gives over a small percentage of its episodes to the capture of new creatures. It tends to be the preference of the detractors in question, however, to ignore the fact that the "Mini-Con of the Week" focus disappeared ''completely'' as the series moved into its second half, and that the comic series was ''never'' like that (among other things, the comic Mini-Cons were every bit as verbose as their "[[bulk]]" brethren).
'''Pokeformers''' is a derogatory term often used to refer to the [[Armada (franchise)|''Armada'' franchise]] by members of the Transformers fandom who weren't particularly fond of the series. The term is a [[wikipedia:portmanteau|portmanteau]] of the words "[[Wikipedia:Pokémon|Pokémon]]" and "Transformers".
 
   
 
Although the "collection" aspect was enough of a similarity for people to draw comparisons between the two franchises (in both fair and unfair ways), it didn't seem to be at the true heart of the issue. Rather, the ''Armada'' show had a lot of stereotypical anime conventions (which had been seen in Transformers [[Robots in Disguise|before]]), was marketed for pre-teens, and wasn't always serious: all traits shared with ''Pokemon'' - and hundreds of other shows. Essentially, this is a comparison made primarily by people who disliked ''Armada'' and wanted to make it sound dumb by associating it with something else they disliked (and assumed other people disliked as well).
Some fans began referring to ''Armada'' as "Pokeformers" because of superficial similarities between the two franchise's premises: each featured a collection of small, cute characters with amazing powers and [[Targetmaster#Japanese Targetmasters|limited vocal skills]] which buyers were urged to collect as many of as they could. The ''Armada'' animated series did little to help refute this comparison, with the first half of the show featuring virtually nothing ''but'' the Transformers searching for new Mini-Cons in an attempt to "collect them all" - ironically taking the theme to an even greater extent than the Pokémon cartoon itself, which only gives over a small percentage of its episodes to the capture of new creatures. It tends to be the preference of the detractors in question, however, to ignore the fact that the "Mini-Con of the Week" focus disappeared ''completely'' as the series moved into its second half, and that the comic series was ''never'' like that (among other things, the comic Mini-Cons were every bit as verbose as their "[[bulk]]" brethren).
 
   
 
It could be fairly stated that both ''Pokémon'' and ''Armada'' simply tapped into a tried and true marketing approach [[to sell toys|to sell their product]]. Furthermore, ''Armada'' was far from the first ''Transformers'' [[franchise]] to use the "[[combiner|Collect them all!]]" approach; it has been a common marketing theme of the [[Transformers brand]] (actually, ''every'' toy franchise) since its inception.
Although the "collection" aspect was enough of a similarity for people to draw comparisons between the two franchises (in both fair and unfair ways), it didn't seem to be at the true heart of the issue. Rather, the ''Armada'' show had a lot of stereotypical anime conventions (which had been seen in Transformers [[Robots in Disguise|before]]), was marketed for pre-teens, and wasn't always serious: all traits shared with ''Pokemon''...and hundreds of other shows. Essentially, this is a comparison made primarily by people who disliked ''Armada'' and wanted to make it sound dumb by associating it with something else they disliked (and assumed other people disliked as well).
 
 
It could be fairly stated that both ''Pokémon'' and ''Armada'' simply tapped into a tried and true marketing approach [[to sell toys|to sell their product]]. Furthermore, ''Armada'' was far from the first ''Transformers'' [[franchise]] to use the "[[combiner|Collect them all!]]" approach; it has been a common marketing theme of the [[Transformers brand]] (actually, ''every'' toy franchise) since its inception. Not to mention every Transformers series involved the two sides fighting for the possession of an object, whether it be [[energon]], a weapon, [[stasis lock]]ed Autobots, or control for [[Cybertron]] and/or the universe itself.
 
   
 
{{-}}
 
{{-}}
  +
  +
Well, throughout the first half of the ''Beast Wars'' series, many episodes were likewise about collecting as many troops as possible, only here by means of retrieving as many stasis pods as possible.
  +
  +
However, to be fair, consider that there are some rather more direct comparisons to be made between Armada and Pokemon. While it is true there have been many shows which hinged on a "collect them all" aspect, consider the manner in which the Mini-cons were "collected". Both come from/are captured by being placed in a smaller shell and are then only called upon when needed in battle, usually by calling out the Pokemon/Mini-con's name. Also, consider the relative sizes of the Pokemon and the Mini-cons, you begin to see a deliberate attempt to emulate the Pokemon look/feel.
  +
  +
"Pokeformer" then should therefore just be a realization that Hasbro/Takara was very consciously trying to emulate a successful aspect of another successful franchise. And given how well the line did ...and what it led to and how very strong the franchise is now, "Pokeformers" may have been alright after all.
  +
 
==Meanwhile==
 
==Meanwhile==
   
[[Image:11rattrap.GIF|center|thumb|[[Rattrap#Beast Wars Metals manga|''This'' happened.]] Thank you, Japan.]]
+
[[Image:11rattrap.GIF|center|thumb|[[Rattrap#Beast Wars Metals manga|''This'' happened.]]]]
  +
[[Image:TFA Swindle with Mud coloured Pokeball.jpg|center|thumb|200px|[[Swindle (Animated)|So did this]].]]
   
  +
==Notes==
  +
* Although "small & cute creatures with limited vocal skills and amazing powers" are cited as parallels between Pokémon and ''[[Transformers: Armada|Armada]]'', a decent proportion of [[Bulbapedia: Pokémon (species)|Pokémon]] are larger than the [[Bulbapedia: Ash Ketchum|main]] [[Bulbapedia: Ash's friends|human characters]], while most [[Mini-Con]]s are around half the size of the main human characters. The "cute" bit is also usually wrong, as not only are a [[Bulbapedia: Gyarados (Pokémon)|fair]] [[Bulbapedia: Charizard (Pokémon)|amount]] [[Bulbapedia: Venusayr (Pokémon)|of]] [[Bulbapedia: Steelix (Pokémon)|Pokémon]] [[Bulbapedia: Druddigon (Pokémon)|species]] are not winning any beauty contests any time soon, but there are a few "[[Shockwave (Cybertron)|less cute]]" Mini-Cons as well. Also of falsity is the [[Bulbapedia: Pokémon language|"limited vocal skills"]] bit, as both Pokémon and Mini-Cons have their own languages, both of which may outstrip the English language in complexity, and can understand humans quite well.
   
  +
{{essay}}
 
[[Category:Armada]]
 
[[Category:Armada]]
 
[[Category:Fandom]]
 
[[Category:Fandom]]

Revision as of 22:00, 25 September 2012

Pokeformers is a derogatory term often used to refer to the Armada franchise by members of the Transformers fandom who weren't particularly fond of the series. The term is a portmanteau of the words "Pokémon" and "Transformers".

Some fans began referring to Armada as "Pokeformers" because of superficial similarities between the two franchise's premises: each featured a collection of small, cute characters with amazing powers and limited vocal skills which buyers were urged to collect as many of as they could, as well as having similar-sounding names. The Armada animated series did little to help refute this comparison, with the first half of the show featuring virtually nothing but the Transformers searching for new Mini-Cons in an attempt to "collect them all" - ironically taking the theme to an even greater extent than the Pokémon cartoon itself, which only gives over a small percentage of its episodes to the capture of new creatures. It tends to be the preference of the detractors in question, however, to ignore the fact that the "Mini-Con of the Week" focus disappeared completely as the series moved into its second half, and that the comic series was never like that (among other things, the comic Mini-Cons were every bit as verbose as their "bulk" brethren).

Although the "collection" aspect was enough of a similarity for people to draw comparisons between the two franchises (in both fair and unfair ways), it didn't seem to be at the true heart of the issue. Rather, the Armada show had a lot of stereotypical anime conventions (which had been seen in Transformers before), was marketed for pre-teens, and wasn't always serious: all traits shared with Pokemon - and hundreds of other shows. Essentially, this is a comparison made primarily by people who disliked Armada and wanted to make it sound dumb by associating it with something else they disliked (and assumed other people disliked as well).

It could be fairly stated that both Pokémon and Armada simply tapped into a tried and true marketing approach to sell their product. Furthermore, Armada was far from the first Transformers franchise to use the "Collect them all!" approach; it has been a common marketing theme of the Transformers brand (actually, every toy franchise) since its inception.

Well, throughout the first half of the Beast Wars series, many episodes were likewise about collecting as many troops as possible, only here by means of retrieving as many stasis pods as possible.

However, to be fair, consider that there are some rather more direct comparisons to be made between Armada and Pokemon. While it is true there have been many shows which hinged on a "collect them all" aspect, consider the manner in which the Mini-cons were "collected". Both come from/are captured by being placed in a smaller shell and are then only called upon when needed in battle, usually by calling out the Pokemon/Mini-con's name. Also, consider the relative sizes of the Pokemon and the Mini-cons, you begin to see a deliberate attempt to emulate the Pokemon look/feel.

"Pokeformer" then should therefore just be a realization that Hasbro/Takara was very consciously trying to emulate a successful aspect of another successful franchise. And given how well the line did ...and what it led to and how very strong the franchise is now, "Pokeformers" may have been alright after all.

Meanwhile

Notes

  • Although "small & cute creatures with limited vocal skills and amazing powers" are cited as parallels between Pokémon and Armada, a decent proportion of Pokémon are larger than the main human characters, while most Mini-Cons are around half the size of the main human characters. The "cute" bit is also usually wrong, as not only are a fair amount of Pokémon species are not winning any beauty contests any time soon, but there are a few "less cute" Mini-Cons as well. Also of falsity is the "limited vocal skills" bit, as both Pokémon and Mini-Cons have their own languages, both of which may outstrip the English language in complexity, and can understand humans quite well.


Bludgeon messagebox
Prattling fool!

This is an essay. It contains speculation, dodgy reasoning, attempts at humor, and other not-suitable information.

You have been warned accordingly.